“Since the advent of Protestant missions, the dominant motivation for missions has been an appeal to the “missionary mandate.” Thus, missions became a response of obedience to a particular set of commands, most notably those texts commonly referred to as embodying the Great Commission. In contrast, Lesslie Newbigin has pointed out that in the New Testament we witness not the burden of obeying a command, but rather a vast “explosion of joy.”[1] Jürgen Moltmann described it as the joyous invitation to all peoples to come to a “feast without end.”[2]…
Harry Boer in his Pentecost and Missions rightly points out that none of the key figures in the book of Acts ever makes a direct appeal to any of the Great Commission passages to justify their preaching, even when questions are raised about the emerging Gentile mission. He further points out that the earliest believers who took the initiative to preach the gospel to Gentiles (Acts 11:20) were very likely not even present at any of those post-resurrection commissioning events.”
Read the rest of Tim Tennent’s fine post.




4 comments
Comments feed for this article
November 6, 2009 at 4:48 pm
Neal Barker
I really appreciate this post. To me, saying that we should be “on mission” because of the “great commission” is equivalent to saying that we should “accept Christ” because we dont’ want to go to hell…
November 6, 2009 at 5:05 pm
Jonathan Dodson
Glad you found it helpful.
However, I’m not sure how you see these two things as equivalent? Could you expound?
November 6, 2009 at 5:18 pm
Neal Barker
I just meant in a very generic sense.
I DO think we should be missional, but I’m not sure that Jesus telling his disciples to go into the nations has the greatest impact on that. There are many other reasons, but it seems that church leaders so often point to that as THE reason. Surely Jesus left us much more wisdom about living out our lives in faith than a short command that he gave his disciples concerning spreading the gospel?
Likewise, I DO think that Jesus is the way, the truth and the life, but I do not believe that the primary reason for people to accept that is to avoid going to hell. But, again, that is something that has been overemphasized over the years, and many Christians point to that as the reason for their belief. Obviously, this causes some issues with how to live out your faith (missional) when the whole reason for that faith is for something that doesn’t come into effect until you are passed from this life.
So, however clear or muddy those thoughts are, that is why I said that I view them similarly. Am I totally off?
November 7, 2009 at 7:46 pm
Jonathan Dodson
Oh, got generic, sorry!
Yeah, when Jesus tells us stuff it shouldn’t have much impact. Wait, did you just write that?! Just kidding, kindof. I think what you are getting at is that “What Jesus demands he supplies.” Look to him for motivation and command, not just command?